Event Details
Food
Add items to your cart
Minimum order $300.00
$300 food & beverage delivery minimum
$30.00 & up delivery fee
Similar caterers
See all

The BlackSheep
465 NY-25A, Miller Place, NY•More info
$30 & up
Delivery Fee
Catering Menu
Appetizers
Grandpa Al's Beef Sticks
Most ordered
Individual Packaging
Ginger-soy marinated flank steak skewers. Served with sesame peanut sauce.
$16.00|Serves 2
Aiden's Favorite Pretzel
Individual Packaging
Giant Bavarian pretzel. Served with beer cheese sauce and spicy mustard.
$15.00|Serves 2
Nacho Average Chip
Individual Packaging
Tortilla chips topped with a three-cheese blend, pico de gallo, sour cream, and guacamole.
$10.00|Serves 2
Lilly's Little Pickle
Individual Packaging
Fried pickle chips. Served with horseradish cream sauce.
$10.95|Serves 2
Gino's Feathered Wing
Individual Packaging
With your choices of flavor & ranch or bleu cheese and celery.
$14.00|Serves 2
Gramp's Roasted Garlic Northern Bean Dip
Individual Packaging
Served with toasted pita, Kalamata olives, roasted peppers, and feta. Topped with extra virgin olive oil.
$12.00|Serves 2
Sandwiches & Burgers
Andrew's Pesto Chicken Sandwich
Individual Packaging
Your choice of grilled or fried chicken cutlet, pesto aioli, goat cheese, roasted peppers, arugula, and balsamic glaze on toasted garlic bread. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$15.00
Between The Herd Sandwich
Individual Packaging
Grilled steak, arugula, mozzarella cheese, fried onions, and roasted garlic aioli on toasted garlic bread. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$15.95
Pat's Blackened Tuna Sandwich
Individual Packaging
With seared ahi tuna, pickled cucumber, mango salsa, and chipotle aioli. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$17.95
Cousin Joe's Chopped Cheese Sandwich
Individual Packaging
Caramelized onions, BlackSheep sauce, lettuce, tomato, and American cheese on toasted garlic bread. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$15.95
Loren's Flying Chick Sandwich
Individual Packaging
With fried chicken thigh, coleslaw, pickles, BBQ chips, and tangy BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$15.95
The Madison Sandwich
Individual Packaging
With BBQ sloppy Joe, caramelized onion, and candied bacon topped with cheddar cheese. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$16.95
The Squealin' Sammie
Individual Packaging
BBQ pulled pork, candied bacon, fried onions, and cheddar on toasted ciabatta. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$16.95
Jacob's Fancy Plant Sandwich
Individual Packaging
With whipped ricotta, fried eggplant, roasted balsamic peppers, arugula, roasted garlic aioli, and pesto on toasted garlic ciabatta. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$15.95
The Blacksheep Burger
Individual Packaging
8oz burger, BlackSheep sauce, lettuce, tomato, and onion on toasted brioche. Served with your choice of french fries or house salad.
$16.95
Bowls
Louise's Poke Bowl
Individual Packaging
Sushi rice with ahi tuna, cucumber, edamame, wakame, and guacamole. Topped with ginger-soy vinaigrette and sesame seeds.
$17.95
Ashley's Taco Bowl
Individual Packaging
Cilantro lime rice with black beans, shredded cheese, lettuce, pico, guacamole, and sour cream.
$12.95
Hot Entrees
Papa's Fish N Chips
Individual Packaging
Beer-battered cod over french fries with coleslaw, caper lemon aioli, and fresh lemon.
$16.95
Dan's Favorite Waffle
Individual Packaging
Savory rosemary thyme waffle with fried chicken thigh, hot honey, and powdered sugar.
$14.95
Braise Your Belly
Individual Packaging
Ginger-soy marinated braised pork belly over lemon grass grits. Topped with pickled vegetable salad and sesame ginger-soy glaze.
$16.95
Me-Mah's Mac & Cheese
Individual Packaging
Creamy mac & cheese topped with garlic herb crumbs and fried onions.
$12.00
Soups & Salads
Soup Du Jour
Individual Packaging
Soup of the day.
$7.00
Salad & Soup Combo
Individual Packaging
$13.95
Greek Salad
Individual Packaging
Iceberg lettuce with red onion, olives, feta, and toasted pita.
$13.95
Arugula Salad
Individual Packaging
Crisp arugula with tomato, cucumber, dried cranberry, goat cheese, candied walnut, and honey vanilla vinaigrette.
$15.00
Aunt Kathy's Street Corn Salad
Individual Packaging
Mesclun mix with tomato, roasted corn, fried jalapeños, red onions, guacamole, queso fresco, lime crème freche, and chipotle ranch.
$16.00
The Abi Wedge
Individual Packaging
Wedge of iceberg lettuce with roasted tomatoes, candied bacon, bleu cheese crumble, soft-boiled egg, and bleu cheese dressing.
$15.00
Sides
Beer Cheese Sauce
Individual Packaging
$2.00
French Fries
Individual Packaging
$7.00
Coleslaw
Individual Packaging
$2.00
Cheese Sauce
Individual Packaging
$1.50
Candied Bacon
Individual Packaging
$7.00
Bacon
Individual Packaging
$5.00
Fried Onions
Individual Packaging
$1.50
Avocado
Individual Packaging
$3.00
Desserts
Grandma Laura's Favorite Hash
Individual Packaging
Decadent chocolate, marshmallow, and walnut squares.
$8.95
Fatally Yours
Individual Packaging
Flourless chocolate cake with raspberry coulis and whipped cream.
$8.95
Nona's Cookies w/ Milk
Individual Packaging
Fresh baked chocolate chip cookies. Served with milk.
$8.95
Beverages
Assorted Individual Sodas
Most ordered
$3.00
Bottled Water
$3.00
Iced Tea
$3.00
Powerade
$3.00
About The BlackSheep Catering
On ezCater.com since January 26th, 2026.
Address
465 NY-25A
Miller Place, NY 11764
Miller Place, NY 11764
Delivery Hours
Mon: 10:30am-3pm, Wed-Thu: 10:30am-7pm, Fri-Sat: 11am-8pm, Sun: 10:30am-6pmTakeout Hours
Mon: 10:30am-3pm, Wed-Thu: 10:30am-7pm, Fri-Sat: 11am-8pm, Sun: 10:30am-6pmDelivery Fee
$30.00 & up to this locationChanging your order
Make changes no later than 6 business hours before event time. Restaurant may not be able to accommodate all requests.Cancelling your order
25% fee if canceled within 24 hours of event timeDelivery Minimum
$300.00 minimum for Delivery