Sarah’s Handmade Ice Cream

Need a larger amount of ice cream for a group? Our 1.5 gallon tub is custom made for your order and kept in our blast freezer (-30 degrees) for easy transport.

Need a large amount of ice cream for a crowd? Our tubs provide 3 gallons of ice cream, which are custom made for your order and kept in our blast freezer (-30 degrees) for easy transport.

Dreamed of creating your own flavor with Sarah? You'll consult your flavor with Sarah and she will customize your very own flavor. We'll then kept it in our blast freezer (-30 degrees) for easy transport a day before your desired pick up date.

Perfect for any events for all ages! This catering option allows every guest to enjoy a scoop without anyone having to scoop.

Mix and match up to 2 flavors.

Can't decide? Try Sarah's Signature 6-flavor Ice Cream Flight! Perfect to indulge, share, and explore!

Enjoy a single scoop split into two flavors—double the taste, same scoop size!

Award winning: Best of Bethesda! Our signature doggie ice creams are made with all-natural, human-grade ingredients with no added sugar. Ingredients: organic peanut butter, organic pure pumpkin, organic greek yogurt, organic local honey, and dried beef liver. Pup cups come very frozen, so that dogs can take their time enjoying them, which also makes it easy to portion-control.

2 scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, and cherry.

Classic sundae with a chocolate chip cookie to satisfy your cravings!

2 scoops of ice cream, Sarah's brownie, hot fudge, whipped cream, and cherry.

Sliced banana, 3 scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, peanuts, and cherry.

Pre-made 9-inch Oreo Lover ice cream cake with thin layers of chocolate cake on top and bottom.

Pre-made 9-inch ice cream pie with graham cracker crust!

Create your own 9-inch ice cream pie.

Customize your own 9 inch ice cream cake.

Pick your ice cream flavor on either chocolate chip cookies or brownie.

6 mini ice cream sandwiches made with Tate's cookies with custom flavors.

Freshly baked in shop every 2 hours.

Choose fun toppings to share with the whole family.

Sarah's homemade fudge brownie.

16 oz milkshake made with your choice of ice cream. Optional complimentary chocolate drizzle and/or whipped cream.

Choice of soda and scoop of ice cream.

Cold brew coffee with a scoop of ice cream.

Perfect to quench your thirst on a hot summer day! Sparkling soda with your choice of sorbet flavor. Vegan friendly.