Event Details
Food
Add items to your cart
Minimum order $25.00
$25 food & beverage delivery minimum
$30.00 & up delivery fee
Similar caterers
See all

Pies on 37
1311 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ•More info
$30 & up
Delivery Fee
Catering Menu
Appetizers
Cheese Balls
$9.95|Serves 2
Jalapeño Poppers
6 pcs.
$8.95|Serves 2
Onion Rings
$7.95|Serves 2
Fried Mushrooms
Served with your choice of sauce.
$9.95|Serves 2
Zucchini Sticks
Served with ranch.
$9.95|Serves 2
Sweet Potato Fries
$7.50|Serves 2
Soup of the Day
$7.95|Serves 2
Meatballs
3 pcs.
$9.95|Serves 2
Sausage
3 pcs.
$9.95|Serves 2
Mussels
$15.95|Serves 2
Fried Calamari
$15.95|Serves 2
Fries
$6.95|Serves 2
Cheese Fries
$7.95|Serves 2
Garlic Knots
6 pcs.
$4.95|Serves 2
Eggplant Rollatini
2 pcs.
$9.95|Serves 2
Eggplant Stack
$8.95|Serves 2
Chicken Fingers
4 pieces. Served with fries.
$12.99|Serves 2
Garlic Bread
$4.95|Serves 2
Garlic Bread With Cheese
$5.95|Serves 2
Mozzarella Caprese
Fresh mozzarella, Jersey tomatoes, roasted peppers, balsamic glaze, and fresh basil.
$14.95|Serves 2
Mozzarella Sticks
$8.50|Serves 2
Antipasto Platters
Antipasto Platter
Salami roses, prosciutto, soppressata, sharp provolone, mozzarella, artichokes, olives, roasted peppers, cherry tomatoes, pepperoncini, and giardiniera. All finished with marinated garlic, olive oil and balsamic drizzle.
$69.99|Serves 8
Mix And Match
Mix And Match
Your choice of 4 entrees and 1 side.
$250.00|Serves 15
Catering Trays
Antipasto Salad Tray
$60.00|Serves 8
Garden Salad Tray
$55.00|Serves 8
Paisano Salad Tray
$70.00|Serves 8
Caesar Salad Tray
$55.00|Serves 8
Roasted Potatoes Tray
$60.00|Serves 8
Stuffed Shells Tray
$60.00|Serves 8
Baked Ziti Tray
$60.00|Serves 8
Penne Vodka Tray
$60.00|Serves 8
Stuffed Rigatoni Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Tortellini Alfredo Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Cavatelli And Broccoli Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Mussels Marinara Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Chicken Parmesan Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Shrimp Scampi Tray
$95.00|Serves 8
Sausage And Peppers Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Meatballs Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Buffalo Wings Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Chicken Fingers Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Mozzarella Caprese Tray
$70.00|Serves 8
Chicken Vodka Parm Tray
$70.00|Serves 8
Chicken Marsala Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Chicken Francese Tray
$65.00|Serves 8
Eggplant Parmesan Tray
$55.00|Serves 8
Eggplant Rollatini Tray
$70.00|Serves 8
Wings
Regular Wings
Served with sauce on the side or dipped in sauce.
$9.95
Boneless Wings
Served with with your choice of dip and sauce.
$7.95
Pizza
Plain Pie Pizza
$15.45|Serves 3
Bar Pie Pizza (Large 16")
Thinner than thin crust.
$16.45|Serves 5
White Pie Pizza
$15.50|Serves 3
Grandma Pie Pizza (Large 16")
Thin, square crust with fresh mozzarella, basil and red sauce.
$23.45|Serves 5
Sicilian (Large 16")
$21.00|Serves 6
Sicilian Pizza Bread (Large 16")
Our Sicilian pizza topped with our special sauce, light garlic and Parmesan cheese, perfect for a party appetizer.
$23.00|Serves 6
Gluten Free Pizza (12")
$14.95|Serves 2
Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza (10")
$13.95
Gourmet Pizza
Chicken Vodka Sauce Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Chicken Marsala PIzza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Chicken Francese Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Large.
$25.95|Serves 5
Special Pizza
Large. Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers.
$23.95|Serves 5
Cheesesteak Pizza
Large. Peppers, onions and mushrooms.
$23.95|Serves 5
Hot Honey Margherita Pizza
Large. Fresh mozzarella, basil, pepperoni cups and hot honey.
$25.95|Serves 5
Veggie Pizza
Large. Onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli.
$23.50|Serves 5
Chicken Bacon & Ranch Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Chicken Wing Pizza
Large. Your choice of wing flavor.
$23.50|Serves 5
16" Sicilian Special Pizza
Large. Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers.
$25.95|Serves 6
Chicken Murphy Pizza
Large. Peppers, onions, hot peppers and potatoes.
$24.50|Serves 5
Five Cheese Pizza
Large.
$22.50|Serves 5
Margherita Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Meat Lovers Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Mac And Cheese Pizza
Large.
$25.00|Serves 5
Bacon, Mac And Cheese Pizza
Large.
$26.00|Serves 5
Balsamic Chicken Pizza
Large.
$25.00|Serves 5
Penne Vodka Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Baked Ziti Pizza
Large.
$23.50|Serves 5
Chipotle Chicken Cheesesteak Pizza
Large.
$24.50|Serves 5
Pickle Pie Pizza
Large.
$22.00|Serves 5
Hawaiian Pizza
Large.
$23.00|Serves 5
Burrata Margherita
Large. The queen of cheese over our delicious sauce topped with arugula and balsamic drizzle.
$30.00|Serves 5
Big Mac Pizza
Large. Ground beef topped with cheese, lettuce, pickles, onions and our special sauce.
$30.00|Serves 5
Stromboli
Pepperoni & Cheese Stromboli
$12.50
Cheesesteak Stromboli
Peppers, onions, mushrooms.
$13.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli
$13.50
Chicken Parmigiana Stromboli
$13.50
Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Pepperoni & Mozzarella Stromboli
$13.50
Vegetarian Stromboli
Peppers, onions, mushrooms, broccoli.
$13.50
Calzones
Cheesesteak Calzone
Peppers, onions, mushrooms.
$14.00
Veggie Calzone
Peppers, onions, mushrooms, broccoli.
$13.50
Ham Calzone
$13.50
Cheese Calzone
Mozzarella and ricotta.
$12.50
Entreés
Chicken Alla Prosciutto
Chicken sautéed with butter & wine topped with prosciutto & mozzarella on a bed of spinach. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken breast seasoned & baked under a layer of blended Italian cheese. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Veal Parmesan
Veal seasoned and baked under a layer of blended Italian cheese. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Chicken Piccata
Chicken breast sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce with mushrooms and capers. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Grilled Chicken Dinner
Served with sautéed broccoli. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Caprese
Breaded cutlet topped with ricotta cheese, eggplant, mozzarella & tomato sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Francese
Tender chicken breast battered in eggs & sautéed in our white wine & lemon sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Murphy
Chicken breast, potatoes, onions and hot peppers in a white wine sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Cacciatore
Tender pieces of chicken, mixed peppers, onions & mushrooms in marinara sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Marsala
Chicken breast sautéed in a light marsala wine, accompanied by fresh mushrooms. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Garden
Chicken with broccoli, mushrooms & tomatoes in a garlic wine sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken & sausage combined with mushrooms, onions & wine in a pink sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Chicken Pisano
Chicken breast, eggplant, mushrooms and roasted red peppers in a cream wine sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$20.99
Seafood
Mussels Marinara
Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Shrimp Vodka Sauce
Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Shrimp Parmigiana
Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a sauce, covered in mozzarella and baked. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Grilled Shrimp Dinner
Served with sautéed broccoli. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Calamari Alla Marinara
Sautéed in wine, garlic and our own marinara. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Fried Shrimp
Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Shrimp Scampi
Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a wine, butter and garlic sauce with fresh lemon. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Shrimp Marinara
Sautéed with garlic and wine in our marinara. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a garlic wine and spicy marinara sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Shrimp Garden
Shrimp with broccoli, mushrooms and tomatoes in a garlic wine sauce. Served with pasta, salad and bread.
$21.99
Specialty Pasta
Stuffed Rigatoni Vodka
Served with a salad and bread.
$19.00
Cavatelli And Broccoli
Served with a salad and bread.
$17.00
Stuffed Shells
Served with a salad and bread.
$16.50
Penne Puttanesca
Marinara, capers and black olives. Served with a salad and bread.
$17.95
Pasta Primavera
Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic. Served with a salad and bread.
$17.95
Pasta Primavera With Grilled Chicken
Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic. Served with a salad and bread.
$20.95
Pasta Primavera With Grilled Shrimp
Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic. Served with a salad and bread.
$22.95
Baked Ziti
Served with a salad and bread.
$16.50
Baked Ziti Sicilian-Style
With chopped eggplant. Served with a salad and bread.
$17.50
Cheese Ravioli
Served with a salad and bread.
$16.50
Fettuccine Alfredo
Served with a salad and bread.
$17.95
Fettuccine Alfredo With Grilled Chicken
Served with a salad and bread.
$20.95
Fettuccine Alfredo With Grilled Shrimp
Served with a salad and bread.
$22.95
Eggplant Parmigiana
Served with a salad and bread.
$18.95
Eggplant Rollatini
Served with a salad and bread.
$19.95
Cheese Tortellini
Served with a salad and bread.
$18.00
Tortellini Carbonara
Alfredo sauce, prosciutto and peas. Served with a salad and bread.
$19.95
Stuffed Rigatoni Sebastian
Topped with vodka sauce, melted mozzarella and breaded chicken. Served with a salad and bread.
$21.95
Lasagna
Homemade meat lasagna topped with melted mozzarella and tomato sauce. Served with a salad and bread.
$16.95
Pasta
Tomato Sauce
$14.00
Marinara
$14.00
Meatball
$15.00
Sausage
$15.00
Oil And Garlic
$14.50
Butter And Garlic
$14.50
Meat Sauce
$16.50
Vodka Sauce
$16.50
Clam Sauce
With your choice of sauce.
$17.50
Cold Subs
Ham, Provolone & Salami Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$10.50
Ham, Provolone & Capicola Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$10.50
Ham, Provolone, Salami & Capicola Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$10.95
BLT Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$10.50
Roast Beef Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$12.95
Turkey Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$11.95
Roast Beef And Turkey Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$11.95
Tuna Sub
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil and vinegar. Cold subs are sliced fresh and made to order.
$10.50
Hot Subs
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
$10.50
Veal Parmigiana Sub
$10.50
Shrimp Parmigiana Sub
$10.50
Sausage Parmigiana Sub
$10.50
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
$10.50
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
$10.50
Chicken Vodka Parmigiana Sub
$10.50
Italian Hot Dog Sub
$10.50
Pepper And Egg Sub
$10.50
California Chicken Sandwich
Breaded chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo.
$10.50
Sausage And Peppers Sub
With onion and marinara.
$10.50
Italiano Sub
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic glaze.
$10.50
Cheesesteaks
Plain Cheesesteak
With American cheese.
$10.50
Special Cheesesteak
Peppers, onions, mushrooms, and American cheese.
$11.50
Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak
With American cheese and buffalo sauce.
$11.50
California Cheesesteak
Lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, and American cheese.
$11.50
Pizza Steak
With sauce, mozzarella, and American cheese.
$12.50
Chicken Cheesesteak
Comes with American cheese.
$11.50
Chipotle Chicken Cheesesteak
Comes with American cheese.
$11.50
Wraps
Veggie Wrap
Eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms.
$12.95
Turkey BLT Wrap
Thinly sliced turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayo, American cheese.
$14.95
Greek Wrap
Romaine lettuce, grape tomato, Gaeta olives, feta cheese, balsamic glaze, mushrooms.
$12.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap
Fried chicken, bacon, ranch, lettuce, tomato.
$14.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Grilled or breaded chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, provolone, bleu cheese.
$14.95
Chicken Caesar
Grilled chicken, crisp romaine, Parmesan cheese, creamy Caesar dressing.
$13.95
Ranchero Wrap
Fried chicken, bacon, American, provolone, ranch dressing.
$14.95
Italiano Wrap
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze.
$13.95
Paninis
Buffalo Chicken Panini
Grilled or breaded buffalo chicken, provolone, bleu cheese. Served with a pickle.
$13.95
Caprese Panini
Fresh mozzarella, Jersey tomatoes, pesto spread, balsamic glaze. Served with a pickle.
$14.95
Chicken Parmesan Panini
Your choice of sauce. Served with a pickle.
$13.95
Siciliano Panini
Eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze. Served with a pickle.
$14.95
New Yorker Panini
Roast beef, Swiss, sautéed onion, deli mustard. Served with a pickle. Served with a pickle.
$14.95
Chipotle Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken, American cheese, lettuce, tomato with chipotle sauce. Served with a pickle.
$13.95
Godfather Panini
Prosciutto, roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella topped with balsamic glaze. Served with a pickle.
$14.95
Ella Panini
Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, pesto spread, balsamic glaze. Served with a pickle.
$14.95
Spinach And Artichoke Panini
Sautéed spinach, artichoke, fresh mozzarella and garlic Parmesan sauce. Served with a pickle.
$14.95
Salads
Antipasto
Iceberg lettuce, roasted peppers, cucumber, black and green olives, red onion, tomato, ham, salami, provolone, fresh mozzarella.
$14.95
Chef Salad
Roast beef, turkey, provolone, iceberg lettuce, red onion, cucumber, tomato, black and green olives.
$14.95
Garden Salad
Iceberg lettuce, cucumber, black and green olives, tomato, red onion.
$11.00
Buffalo Bleu Salad
Iceberg and romaine mix; buffalo grilled chicken, grape tomato, cucumber and chunky bleu cheese dressing.
$14.95
Calista Salad
Romaine, eggplant, prosciutto, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, provolone, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, cucumber, olives & red onion.
$16.00
Greek Salad
Romaine, Gaeta olives, feta cheese, grape tomato, red onion.
$11.00
Paisano Salad
Romaine, grilled chicken, roasted peppers, cucumber, olives, red onion, artichoke heart, bacon, fresh mozzarella, house vinaigrette.
$14.95
Autumn Salad
Romaine, grilled chicken, walnut, craisins, red onion, feta cheese.
$14.95
California Chicken Salad
Iceberg lettuce, breaded chicken, tomato, red onion, cucumber, olives.
$14.95
Caesar Salad
$12.95
Boom Boom Shrimp Salad
Jumbo shrimp tossed in boom boom sauce & served over romaine with cherry tomatoes, bacon, fresh mozzarella, cucumber and red onion.
$16.50
Desserts
Cheesecake
$5.95
Choc Mousse Cake
$6.95
Choc Mud Pie
$6.95
Chocolate Chip Cookies
$5.00|Serves 2
Single Chocolate Chip Cookie
$3.00
Cannoli
$5.95
About Pies on 37 Catering
On ezCater.com since August 25th, 2026.
Address
1311 NJ-37
Toms River, NJ 08755
Toms River, NJ 08755
Delivery Hours
Mon-Thu: 11am-9pm, Fri-Sat: 11am-10pm, Sun: 11am-9pmTakeout Hours
Mon-Thu: 11am-9pm, Fri-Sat: 11am-10pm, Sun: 11am-9pmDelivery Fee
$30.00 & up to this locationChanging your order
Make changes no later than 6 business hours before event time. Restaurant may not be able to accommodate all requests.Cancelling your order
25% fee if canceled within 24 hours of event timeDelivery Minimum
$25.00 minimum for Delivery