Oddfellows Ice Cream
$30 & up
Delivery Fee
Catering Menu
Catering Packages
Most ordered
Your choice of 4 ice cream flavors and 6 toppings. 14oz pint each.
$65.00|Serves 8
Your choice of 3 flavors. 14oz pint each.
$30.00|Serves 6
Your choice of 6 flavors. 14oz pint each.
$60.00|Serves 12
Classic Ice Cream
Most ordered
Individual Packaging
Sweet cream ice cream with crunchy rainbow sprinkles. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Sweet cream ice cream studded with chocolate cookie bits. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Strawberry ice cream swirled with ribbons of strawberry jam. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Dark chocolate ice cream swirled with chunks of dark chocolate. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Coffee ice cream with coffee soil. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Vanilla ice cream made with real Madagascar vanilla beans. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Sweet cream ice cream with salted caramel swirls, and chocolate coated toffee chunks. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Chocolate ice cream with chunks of house-made chocolate cake, and chocolate pudding swirls. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Sweet cream ice cream with crushed Oreos, chocolate chip cookie rainbow, and rainbow sprinkles. 14oz pint.
$11.50|Serves 4
OddFellows Favorite Ice Cream
Individual Packaging
Passionfruit ice cream swirled with pistachios and apricot jam ribbons.
$12.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Peanut butter ice cream with graham cracker soil, dark chocolate chunks, and mini marshmallows.
$12.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Creamy white miso ice cream swirled with sweet candied cherries.
$12.50|Serves 4
Vegan Ice Cream
Individual Packaging
Dark chocolate cashew milk vegan ice cream with dark chocolate chunks, and contains cashew and coconut oil.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Non dairy blend of banana, mango, passionfruit, and guava, and contains coconut oil.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Chocolate and mint cashew-based ice cream with crushed chocolate cookies, and contains nuts, gluten, and coconut oil.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Coconut-based ice cream with mango swirls and gobs of mochi rice.
$11.50|Serves 4
Individual Packaging
Creamy coconut milk ice cream delicately infused with aromatic pandan.
$11.50|Serves 4
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Individual Packaging
Your choice of ice cream squished between 2 chocolate chip cookies.
$9.50
Beverages
$3.00
$4.00
About Oddfellows Ice Cream Catering
On ezCater.com since November 20th, 2025.
See all Oddfellows Ice Cream Catering locationsAddress
44 Water St
Brooklyn, NY 11201
Brooklyn, NY 11201
Delivery Hours
Mon-Sun: 12pm-10pmTakeout Hours
Mon-Sun: 12pm-10pmDelivery Fee
$30.00 & up to this locationChanging your order
Make changes no later than 6 business hours before event time. Restaurant may not be able to accommodate all requests.Cancelling your order
25% fee if canceled within 24 hours of event timeDelivery Minimum
$50.00 minimum for Delivery