Lillo’s Tomato Pies
83%
On Time
$0 & up
Delivery Fee
Catering Menu
Sandwich Boxes
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch cheesesteak made with 8 oz shaved ribeye, with your choice of cheese and toppings, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch turkey & cheese with traditional hoagie toppings, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$15.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch chicken cheesesteak made with fresh chicken breast and your choice of cheese and toppings, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch hand-breaded chicken cutlet with seasoned roasted red peppers, fresh spinach, fresh wet mozzarella, balsamic glaze, and Pecorino Romano, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch hand-breaded chicken cutlet topped with house-made marinara, and melted mozzarella, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.99
Individual Packaging
House-made meatballs topped with house-made marinara and melted mozzarella. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch chicken cutlet prepared caesar-style, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch italian hoagie with italian meats & cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, and oregano, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch sandwich with slow-roasted pork, broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, fresh garlic, and Pecorino Romano, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch sandwich with fresh chicken breast, cooper sharp, and buffalo sauce, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$17.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch sandwich with fresh chicken breast, cooper sharp, cupping pepperoni, and hot honey, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch sandwich with shaved ribeye, cooper sharp, and house-made marinara, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$17.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch sandwich with shaved ribeye, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$17.99
Individual Packaging
Loaded 6-inch sandwich with 8 oz premium thin-sliced steak, sliced potatoes, green peppers, mayo, and ketchup, served on a seeded Italian roll. Served with chips. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$26.99
Appetizer Trays
Crispy French fries. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$27.99|Serves 5
Crispy French fries topped with warm Cheese Wiz. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$34.99|Serves 5
Crispy French fries topped with warm Cheese Wiz and bacon. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$39.99|Serves 5
Sandwiches
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99
Individual Packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$24.99
Sandwich Trays
Hand-breaded chicken cutlet topped with seasoned roasted red peppers, fresh spinach, fresh wet mozzarella, balsamic glaze, and Pecorino Romano. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$69.99|Serves 5
Italian meats and cheese with lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, vinegar, salt, pepper, and oregano on seeded Italian rolls. Seeded Italian roll comes standard. Non-seeded available upon request at no additional charge. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$64.99|Serves 5
Includes 1 roast pork, 1 chicken Parm, 1 meatball Parm, 1 chicken cutlet, and 1 chicken Caesar cutlet. Cut into 20 total shareable pieces. Seeded Italian roll comes standard. Non-seeded available upon request at no additional charge. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$69.99|Serves 5
Sliced turkey and cheese with traditional hoagie toppings on seeded Italian rolls. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$59.99|Serves 5
Hand-breaded chicken cutlet prepared Caesar-style on seeded Italian rolls. Seeded Italian roll comes standard. Non-seeded available upon request at no additional charge. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$64.99|Serves 5
Hand-breaded chicken cutlet topped with house-made marinara and melted mozzarella. Seeded Italian roll comes standard. Non-seeded available upon request at no additional charge. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$69.99|Serves 5
House-made meatballs topped with house-made marinara and melted mozzarella. Seeded Italian roll comes standard. Non-seeded available upon request at no additional charge. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$64.99|Serves 5
Slow-roasted pork with broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, fresh garlic, and Pecorino Romano. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$69.99|Serves 5
Cheesesteak Trays
Most ordered
Made with shaved ribeye and the customer's choice of cheese and toppings. The Full Tray consists of 5 full 12-inch cheesesteaks made with 16 oz of shaved ribeye each and cut into 20 shareable pieces. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$79.99|Serves 5
With chicken breast and your choices of cheese and toppings. Seeded Italian roll comes standard. Non-seeded available upon request at no additional charge. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$79.99|Serves 5
Tomato & Specialty Pies
Most ordered
Thick, square Sicilian-style pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$26.99|Serves 6
Our New Jersey classic made with Grande mozzarella on the bottom and crushed tomato sauce on top, baked on a thin, crispy crust. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$23.99|Serves 4
Our Trenton-style mustard pie. Recommended with sausage and fresh garlic. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$27.99|Serves 4
Topped with mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, and broccoli. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$27.99|Serves 4
White pizza topped with ricotta, fresh garlic, and broccoli. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$25.99|Serves 4
Fresh chicken breast, mozzarella, buffalo sauce, and ranch. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$28.99|Serves 4
Rustic marinara, fresh wet mozzarella, Pecorino Romano, olive oil, oregano, and fresh basil. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$28.99|Serves 4
Topped with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$29.99|Serves 4
18" specialty pie topped with hot honey, cupping pepperoni, and ricotta. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$29.99|Serves 4
Loaded with ham, bacon, meatballs, sausage, and pepperoni. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$30.99|Serves 4
Hot Entrees
Hand-breaded chicken cutlets topped with house-made marinara and melted mozzarella. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$59.99|Serves 5
House-made meatballs simmered in our house-made marinara. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$54.99|Serves 5
Italian sausage with peppers and onions. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$49.99|Serves 5
Hand-breaded chicken cutlets topped with seasoned roasted red peppers, fresh spinach, fresh wet mozzarella, balsamic glaze, and Pecorino Romano. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$64.99|Serves 5
Slow-roasted pork with broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, fresh garlic, and Pecorino Romano. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$69.99|Serves 5
Pasta Trays
Rigatoni tossed in creamy vodka sauce. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$44.99|Serves 5
Angel hair pasta tossed with our house-made marinara. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$39.99|Serves 5
Hand-breaded chicken Parmesan topped with house-made marinara and melted mozzarella, served with angel hair pasta. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$64.99|Serves 5
House-made meatballs and house-made marinara served with angel hair pasta. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$59.99|Serves 5
Baked ziti with house-made marinara and melted mozzarella. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$44.99|Serves 5
Salad Trays
Most ordered
Romaine, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, and croutons. Served with your choice of dressing. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$34.99|Serves 5
Romaine, cherry tomatoes, shaved Parmesan, and croutons. Served with Caesar dressing. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$34.99|Serves 5
Romaine, cherry tomatoes, soppressata, capicola, pepperoni, provolone, fresh wet mozzarella, artichokes, croutons, and balsamic glaze. Served with your choice of dressing. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$44.99|Serves 5
Romaine, topped with grilled chicken breast. cherry tomatoes, shaved Parmesan, and croutons. Served with Caesar dressing. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$44.99|Serves 5
Romaine, cherry tomatoes, house-made meatballs, ricotta, Pecorino Romano, house-made marinara and balsamic glaze. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$49.99|Serves 5
Bread
Approximately 12 garlic knots finished with garlic butter, parsley, and Pecorino Romano. Served with house-made marinara. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.99|Serves 6
Approximately 12 rolls brushed with garlic butter and finished with Pecorino Romano, and parsley. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.99|Serves 6
Six full 12" seeded Italian rolls. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$12.99|Serves 6
Desserts
12 mini cannoli with crispy pastry shells and sweet ricotta filling. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$24.99|Serves 12
Beverages
Most ordered
$4.99
$2.99
$1.99
Miscellaneous
$1.00
About Lillo’s Tomato Pies Catering
On ezCater.com since August 17th, 2026.
Lillo’s Tomato Pies brings the old-school flavors of Chambersburg, Trenton to South Jersey. Family-owned and known for our thin, crispy Trenton tomato pies and loaded cheesesteaks, Lillo’s earned a 9.1 cheesesteak score and an 8.4 tomato pie score from Dave Portnoy. From tomato pies and cheesesteaks to hand-breaded chicken cutlets, house-made Italian favorites, pasta, sandwich trays, boxed lunches and party trays, we make feeding the office, meeting or party easy. Everything is made with the same quality and portions we serve in our restaurant.
See all Lillo’s Tomato Pies Catering locationsAddress
2503 Marne Hwy
Hainesport, NJ 08036
Hainesport, NJ 08036
Delivery Hours
Tue-Sat: 10:30am-6:30pmTakeout Hours
Tue-Sat: 10:30am-6:30pmDelivery Fee
$0.00 & up to this locationChanging your order
Make changes no later than 6 business hours before event time. Restaurant may not be able to accommodate all requests.Cancelling your order
25% fee if canceled within 24 hours of event timeDelivery Minimum
$100.00 minimum for Delivery