Packed with real pumpkin purée and rich white chocolate chips for the ultimate fall cookie.
$42.00|Serves 6
Apple Cider n' Spice Cookies
Warm cinnamon, apple cider, and nutmeg bring cozy orchard flavors to every bite.
$42.00|Serves 6
NYC’s Best Holiday Package
Includes 2 holiday decorated sugar cookies (Marry Cabmas & Snow York City) and 6 chocolate chip gooey cookies.
$72.00|Serves 8
Pumpkin Sweet Loaf
$35.00|Serves 8
Thanksgiving Cookie Pack
Includes 1 Happy Thanksgiving decorated sugar cookie and 5 assorted gooey cookies (flavors may vary).
$50.00|Serves 6
NYC Holiday Package
Includes 3 decorated sugar cookies (Snow York City, Freeze the Day, and Merry Cabmas).
$45.00|Serves 3
Desserts
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pack
Most ordered
Crispy edges, gooey center.
$42.00|Serves 6
Variety Gooey Cookie Pack
Most ordered
Mix of classic & seasonal favorites.
$42.00|Serves 6
Box Of Gluten-Friendly Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies
Includes 12 gluten-friendly vegan chocolate chip cookies made with plant-based butter and gluten-free ingredients. These cookies are made on the same equipment as gluten and dairy products and are not recommended for those with a gluten or dairy allergy.
$42.00|Serves 6
Variety Pack Cuties
An assortment of our fun-sized Gooey Cookies featuring a mix of classic and seasonal flavors — perfect for sharing with a crowd.
$24.00|Serves 6
Box of Crumbfetti
Includes 12 Crumbfetti sprinkle gooey cookies.
$42.00|Serves 6
S'mores Gooey Cookie Box
$42.00|Serves 6
Surprise Me Cookie Pack
Baker's choice.
$39.00|Serves 6
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie Pack
A seasonal favorite, nostalgic oatmeal cookies loaded with chocolate chips (hold the raisins).
$42.00|Serves 6
New York Black & White Cookies
Soft, cakey, and topped with our signature vanilla and chocolate icing.
$36.00|Serves 6
Gooey Cookie Cake
10" giant chocolate chip cookie with gooey center.
$75.00|Serves 8
Bag of Brown Butter Toffee Crisps
Individual Packaging
Thin, golden, and perfectly crunchy crisps with rich brown butter flavor and buttery toffee bits in every bite.