Event Details
Food
Add items to your cart
Minimum order $50.00
$50 food & beverage delivery minimum
$30.00 & up delivery fee
Similar caterers
See all

Eataly Caffe
$30 & up
Delivery Fee
Catering Menu
Breakfast
Mixed Bakery Platter
An assortment of (12) baked goods, including (4) pistachio cream-filled muffins, (4) chocolate-hazelnut spread-filled muffins, and (4) bombolone (Italian-style sugar-coated doughnuts filled w/ pastry cream).
$73.80|Serves 12

Savory Cornetti Platter
An assortment of 8 savory croissants, including (3) Prosciutto di Parma, (3) Ham & Cheese, and (2) Egg Fritatta, Cheese, & Bacon.
$71.20|Serves 8

Sweet Cornetti Platter
An assortment of (8) traditional Italian croissants, including (2) plain, (2) pastry cream-filled, (2) pistachio cream-filled, and (2) chocolate-filled.
$51.80|Serves 8

Assorted Muffins
An assortment of (6) muffins, including whole-wheat blueberry (2), pistachio cream-filled (2), and chocolate-hazelnut spread-filled (2).
$35.40|Serves 6

Catering Packages & Platters
Assorted Panini & Tiramisù Package
Most ordered
Includes (8) Caprese panini halves (heirloom tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & basil on baguettina), (8) tacchino panini halves (roasted turkey breast, gem lettuce, red onion jam & aioli on baguettina), and (2) tiramisù teglia.
$145.00|Serves 8

Classic Salumi e Formaggi Platter
Curated by our expert mongers, this platter features a crowd-pleasing selection of cured meats and cheeses. Cheeses: fresh burrata, pecorino Toscano, and Fontina DOP. Cured meats: mortadella, sopressata salame, and prosciutto cotto. Includes house-made baguette, Taralli crackers, grapes, strawberries, blackberries, and dried fruit.
$195.00|Serves 8

Margherita Pizza & Tiramisù Package
Includes (1) whole pizza alla pala margherita (Roman-style pizza w/ Mutti crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & basil) and (2) tiramisù teglia.
$109.00|Serves 8

Mortadella e Burrata Pizza & Tiramisù Package
Includes (1) whole pizza alla pala mortadella e burrata (Roman-style pizza w/ mortadella, burrata & pistachio) and (2) tiramisù teglia.
$109.00|Serves 8

Pizza Alla Pala
Pizza Margherita
Most ordered
With Mutti crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
$55.00|Serves 10

Pizza Bolognese
With Mutti crushed tomatoes, ragù bolognese, mozzarella, and Grana Padano DOP.
$80.00|Serves 10

Pizza Tricolore
With prosciutto, stracciatella, cherry tomatoes, and arugula.
$95.00|Serves 10

Pizza Cotto e Stracciatella
With prosciutto cotto, mozzarella, stracciatella, and basil.
$80.00|Serves 10

Pizza Soppressata
With Mutti crushed tomatoes, spicy salame, and fresh mozzarella.
$65.00|Serves 10

Pizza Funghi
With roasted cremini mushrooms, button mushrooms, provolone, and mozzarella.
$80.00|Serves 10

Pizza Margherita Rivisitata
With Mutti crushed tomatoes, pesto genovese, mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, and basil.
$65.00|Serves 10

Pizza Mortadella e Burrata
With mortadella, burrata, and pistachio.
$115.00|Serves 10

Panini & Focacce
Panini Selection
Most ordered
Your choice of paninis.
$58.60|Serves 4

Focacce Selection
Most ordered
Your choice of focacce.
$60.60|Serves 4

Main Courses & Pasta Salads
Pasta Salad w/ Fresh Tomato, Mozzarella & Basil
Most ordered
Garofalo pasta, fresh cherry tomatoes, fior di latte mozzarella, basil, extra virgin olive oil.
$75.00|Serves 8

Pasta Salad w/ Spinach Pesto & Ricotta
Most ordered
Garofalo pasta, spinach pesto, black pepper, red crushed pepper, salt (contains walnuts).
$75.00|Serves 8

Polpette
Pork and beef meatballs in housemade mutti tomato sauce.
$75.00|Serves 6

Melanzane alla Parmigiana
Lightly fried eggplant, housemade mutti tomato sauce, housemade mozzarella, basil, Parmigiano Reggiano® DOP.
$65.00|Serves 6

Lasagna Bolognese
Housemade lasagna sheets, pork and beef ragú alla bolognese, bechamel, Parmigiano Reggiano® DOP.
$70.00|Serves 6

Gnocchi Sorrentina
Potato gnocchi, mutti tomato, mozzarella, Grana Padano DOP, basil.
$55.00|Serves 6

Salads
Arugula & Cherry Tomato Salad
Baby arugula, cherry tomatoes, lemon citronette, grana padano dop, sea salt.
$60.00|Serves 6

Caesar Salad w/ Grilled Chicken
Little gem lettuce, grilled chicken, garlic, breadcrumbs, crushed red pepper, black pepper, Caesar dressing, parsley.
$60.00|Serves 6

Bomboloni
Bomboloni Selection
Most ordered
Your choice of Bomboloni (Italian-style sugar-coated doughnut).
$40.70|Serves 5

Italian Desserts
Tartelletta alla Frutta
Pastry cream-filled pie crust topped with fresh berries.
$87.20|Serves 8

Tiramisù
Layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers & mascarpone cream, topped with cocoa powder—gluten-friendly.
$36.80|Serves 6

Babà al Rum
Rum-soaked cake.
$95.20|Serves 8

Panna Cotta
Panna cotta topped with fresh fruit and almond crumble—gluten-friendly.
$36.80|Serves 6

Maritozzo
Roman brioche bun filled with pastry cream and whipped cream.
$87.20|Serves 8

Dessert Bundles
Mixed Cookie Platter
Most ordered
Includes (3) sugar cookies, (3) chocolate chip cookies, and (3) lemon blueberry cookies.
$55.80|Serves 9

Classic Italian Desserts Cups
Most ordered
Individual Packaging
Includes (4) tiramisù monoporzione (layers of espresso-soaked rice flour sponge cake & mascarpone cream topped w/ cocoa powder) and (4) panna cotta monoporzione (topped w/ fresh fruit & almond crumble).
$87.20|Serves 8

Assorted Pasticcini Platter
Most ordered
Includes (10) quadratino al cioccolato (chocolate cake, cream & crunchy hazelnuts), (10) quadratino al lampone (raspberry gelée & pistachio sponge cake), (10) babà al rum (rum-soaked cake), and (10) bignola al pistacchio (pistachio cream puff).
$128.00|Serves 12

DIY Classic Cannoli Kit
Everything you need to make your own cannoli, including (8) traditional Sicilian cannoli shells and a bag of sweet ricotta filling (2 boxes).
$55.20|Serves 8

Southern Italian Dessert Platter
Includes (2) maritozzo (Roman brioche bun filled w/ pastry cream & whipped cream), (2) babà al rum (rum-soaked cake), (2) delizia al limone (lemon cream-filled sponge cake topped w/ lemon whipped cream), and (2) cannoli ricotta (traditional Sicilian cannolo filled w/ sweet ricotta).
$81.20|Serves 8

Mixed Italian Cakes
Includes (2) torta della nonna (Tuscan almond, lemon cream & pine nut tart), (2) torta al pistacchio (layered pistachio mousse cake), (2) torta al cioccolato (flourless chocolate-almond cake), and (2) torta ricotta e pere (hazelnut sponge cake, ricotta cream & pear).
$87.20|Serves 8

DIY Chocolate Cannoli Kit
Everything you need to make your own cannoli, including (8) chocolate-dipped Sicilian cannoli shells and a bag of sweet ricotta filling (2 boxes).
$63.20|Serves 8

Hot Beverages
Regular Drip Coffee
Most ordered
$28.00|Serves 8

Decaf Drip Coffee
$28.00|Serves 8

Black Hot Tea
$23.00|Serves 8

Assorted Hot Teas
Tea bags.
$35.00|Serves 8

Ginger Spice Chai Latte
$45.00|Serves 8

Hot Chocolate
$75.00|Serves 8

Iced Beverages
Half & Half
32 oz.
$7.00|Serves 16
Oat Milk
32 oz.
$8.00|Serves 16
Gallon Whole Milk
$8.00|Serves 8
Lemonade
$30.00|Serves 8

Hibiscus Iced Tea
$30.00|Serves 8

Almond Milk
32 oz.
$8.00|Serves 16
Black Iced Tea
$30.00|Serves 8

Iced Tea w/ Lemonade
With your choice of tea.
$35.00|Serves 8

Cold Brew
$45.00|Serves 8

Iced Ginger Spice Chai Latte
$45.00|Serves 8

Iced Chocolate Milk
$60.00|Serves 8

Gallon Skim Milk
$8.00|Serves 8
Bottled Beverages
Sanpellegrino Zero Soda
11 oz.
$3.49

San Benedetto Still Water
$2.99

San Benedetto Sparkling Water
$2.99

Sanpellegrino Soda
11 oz.
$2.99

San Benedetto Sugar-Free Tea
16.9 oz.
$3.99

Molecola Soda
12.8 oz.
$3.49

About Eataly Caffe Catering
On ezCater.com since July 21st, 2025.
See all Eataly Caffe Catering locationsAddress
1230 Ave of the Americas
New York, NY 10036
New York, NY 10036
Delivery Hours
Mon-Sun: 9am-9pmTakeout Hours
Mon-Sun: 9am-9pmDelivery Fee
$30.00 & up to this locationCancelling your order
100% fee if canceled within 48 hours of event timeDelivery Minimum
$50.00 minimum for Delivery