Buttermilk's Farmhouse
93 East Main St, Bay Shore, NY•More info
100%
On Time
$30 & up
Delivery Fee
Catering Menu
Breakfast Trays
$46.00|Serves 8
$46.00|Serves 8
$46.00|Serves 8
$52.00|Serves 8
$46.00|Serves 8
$74.75|Serves 8
$74.75|Serves 8
$74.75|Serves 8
$74.75|Serves 8
Seasoned shredded potatoes.
$46.00|Serves 8
$52.00|Serves 8
$27.75|Serves 12
Breakfast
Individual Packaging
Two farm fresh eggs cooked to your liking. Served with 2 sides and toast.
$12.95
Individual Packaging
Two farm fresh eggs cooked to your liking. Served with bacon, sausage, ham, 1 side, and toast.
$15.95
Individual Packaging
Buttermilk's savory homemade corned beef hash. Served with two eggs cooked to your liking and choice of 1 side and toast.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
Scrambled eggs, diced ham, peppers, caramelized onions, salsa, Monterey Jack and cheddar cheese, and fresh sliced avocado. Served with your choice of side.
$16.50
Individual Packaging
Scrambled egg whites, turkey, Swiss cheese, baby spinach, mushrooms, and diced tomatoes. Served with your choice of side.
$17.50
Individual Packaging
Scrambled eggs, hash browns, bacon, sausage, and American cheese. Served with your choice of side.
$15.50
Individual Packaging
Sauteed mushrooms, fresh spinach, crispy crumbled bacon, and tangy goat cheese. Served with toast and side.
$15.50
Individual Packaging
Fresh spinach, feta cheese, freshly diced tomatoes, scallions, and a hint of oregano. Served with toast and side.
$15.50
Individual Packaging
Spicy Sriracha marinated chicken, crumbled bleu cheese, and scallions. Served with toast and side.
$16.95
Individual Packaging
Turkey, spinach, sun-dried tomato, caramelized onions, and Swiss cheese. Served with toast and side.
$15.95
Pancakes
Individual Packaging
$8.95
Individual Packaging
Served with your choice of side.
$12.95|Serves 2
Individual Packaging
With slice bananas, crispy crumbled bacon, peanut butter sauce, and chocolate whipped cream.
$10.95
Individual Packaging
With slice bananas, crispy crumbled bacon, peanut butter sauce, and chocolate whipped cream. Served with your choice of side.
$14.95|Serves 2
Individual Packaging
Cinnamon sugar-baked apples cooked right in. Topped with cinnamon crumble and sweet vanilla drizzle.
$10.95
Individual Packaging
Cinnamon sugar-baked apples cooked right in. Topped with cinnamon crumble and sweet vanilla drizzle. Served with your choice of side.
$14.95|Serves 2
Individual Packaging
With brown sugar cinnamon and sweet cream cheese swirl.
$10.95
Individual Packaging
With brown sugar cinnamon and sweet cream cheese swirl. Served with your choice of side.
$14.95|Serves 2
Individual Packaging
Inspired by Girl Scout cookies. Coconut-flavored batter, toasted coconut flakes, chocolate chips, gooey caramel sauce, chocolate syrup, and fresh whipped cream.
$10.95
Individual Packaging
Inspired by Girl Scout cookies. Coconut-flavored batter, toasted coconut flakes, chocolate chips, gooey caramel sauce, chocolate syrup, and fresh whipped cream. Served with your choice of side.
$14.95|Serves 2
Individual Packaging
With rainbow sprinkles, sweet vanilla drizzle, fresh whipped cream.
$10.95
Individual Packaging
With rainbow sprinkles, sweet vanilla drizzle, fresh whipped cream. Served with your choice of side.
$14.95|Serves 2
French Toast
Individual Packaging
Award winning French toast made with cinnamon brioche bread and infused with vanilla egg batter.
$12.95
Individual Packaging
Fluff and chocolate chips sandwiched between two pieces of classic French toast, topped with graham cracker crumbs, chocolate whipped cream, toasted marshmallow, and chocolate drizzle.
$15.95
Individual Packaging
Classic French toast sandwiched with banana, peanut butter, and fluff.
$14.95
Individual Packaging
Cannoli cream stuffed between two pieces of classic French toast, drizzled with chocolate, topped with chocolate whipped cream and crumbled cannoli shells.
$15.95
Individual Packaging
Crunchy fried French toast pieces coated in cinnamon sugar, topped with sweet vanilla drizzle.
$12.95
Individual Packaging
Classic French toast topped with bananas flambéed in caramel sauce, gooey caramel, fresh whipped cream, and cinnamon.
$15.95
Catering Packages
Most ordered
Includes 1/2 tray silver dollar pancakes, 1/2 tray scrambled eggs, 1/2 tray hashbrowns, 1/2 tray bacon, 2 dozen biscuits, and 1/2 tray fruit.
$320.00|Serves 18
Includes 1/4 tray scrambled eggs, 1/4 tray bacon, 1/2 tray hashbrowns, 1/2 tray silver dollar pancakes, and 1 dozen biscuits.
$175.00|Serves 10
Includes 1/2 tray silver dollar pancakes, 1/2 tray scrambled eggs, 1/2 tray hashbrowns, 1/2 tray bacon, and 1 dozen biscuits.
$240.50|Serves 12
Includes full tray waffles, full tray fried chicken, 2 dozen biscuits, 2 quarts sausage gravy, 1/2 tray hashbrowns, and 1/2 tray bacon/.
$435.00|Serves 18
Includes 1/2 tray scrambled eggs, 1/2 tray hashbrowns, full tray cinnamon brioche French toast, full tray BLT sliders, 1/2 tray garden salad, and 1/2 tray coleslaw.
$405.00|Serves 12
Includes 1/2 tray BLT sliders, 1/2 tray potato salad, 1/2 tray garden salad, and 1/2 tray fruit.
$215.00|Serves 10
Lunch Trays
$86.25|Serves 8
$74.75|Serves 8
Buttermilk’s signature fried chicken strips with yellow cheddar cheese on brioche slider rolls. Lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing served on the side.
$74.75|Serves 8
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh spinach, and garlic aioli on sourdough slider rolls.
$74.75|Serves 8
BBQ pulled pork, caramelized onions, mascarpone and goat cheeses, and fig jam on brioche slider rolls.
$74.75|Serves 8
Multigrain slider roll with yellow and white cheddar cheeses, sliced tomato, avocado, and bacon.
$63.25|Serves 8
Sandwiches
Individual Packaging
Buttermilk's signature fried chicken strips, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and Buttermilk's homemade ranch.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
Grilled chicken, spinach, roasted red peppers, sun-dried tomato, fresh mozzarella, and garlic aioli.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
BBQ pulled pork, sliced ham, Swiss, horseradish pickles, and spicy brown mustard.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
Buttermilk tuna salad with crisp bacon, avocado, and lettuce.
$15.95
Individual Packaging
$14.95
Individual Packaging
Classic Reuben sandwich, pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss, and Thousand Island dressing.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
Cheddar cheese, grilled chicken, homemade chunky bleu cheese, dressing with a drizzle of buffalo sauce.
$15.95
Individual Packaging
Bacon, yellow cheddar, white cheddar, avocado, and sliced tomato served on multigrain bread.
$16.95
Individual Packaging
Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, roasted red peppers, spinach, garlic aioli, and balsamic glaze served on ciabatta.
$15.95
Individual Packaging
Mascarpone, goat cheese, fig jam, sauteed onions, and BBQ pulled pork served on brioche bread with cinnamon butter.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
American cheese, bacon, and tomato served on hearty white.
$14.95
Salad Trays
Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, and red onion.
$52.00|Serves 8
Mixed greens, diced green apple, walnuts, dried cranberries, and raspberry vinaigrette.
$63.25|Serves 8
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onion, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and red wine vinaigrette.
$63.25|Serves 8
Mixed greens, diced pears, candied walnuts, dried cranberries, crumbled goat cheese, and champagne vinaigrette.
$63.25|Serves 8
Salads
Individual Packaging
Diced green apples, dried cranberries, walnuts, and grilled chicken served on top of a bed of mixed greens with raspberry vinaigrette.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
Mixed greens, buttermilk signature fried chicken, tomato, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and red onions with homemade red wine vinaigrette.
$17.95
Individual Packaging
Mixed greens, diced pear, tangy goat cheese, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, and homemade creamy champagne vinaigrette.
$13.95
Side Trays
$52.00|Serves 8
$52.00|Serves 8
$46.00|Serves 8
$52.00|Serves 8
$52.00|Serves 8
Beverages
$4.55
$5.85
About Buttermilk's Farmhouse Catering
On ezCater.com since April 30th, 2026.
See all Buttermilk's Farmhouse Catering locationsAddress
93 East Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Delivery Hours
Mon-Sun: 7:30am-3:30pmTakeout Hours
Mon-Sun: 7:30am-3:30pmDelivery Fee
$30.00 & up to this locationChanging your order
Make changes no later than 6 business hours before event time. Restaurant may not be able to accommodate all requests.Cancelling your order
25% fee if canceled within 24 hours of event timeDelivery Minimum
$100.00 minimum for Delivery