Event Details
Food
Add items to your cart
Minimum order $50.00
$50 food & beverage delivery minimum
$25.00 & up delivery fee
Similar caterers
See all

Buttermilk Bake Shop
98%
On Time
$25 & up
Delivery Fee
Cupcakes
Build-Your-Own 12-Pack Cupcakes
Most ordered
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 12 cupcakes.
$44.00|Serves 12
Build-Your-Own 6-Pack Cupcakes
Most ordered
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 6 cupcakes.
$24.00|Serves 6
Gluten-Free Vanilla Chocolate Cupcake
Individual Packaging (Opt)
$4.00
Build-Your-Own 4-Pack Cupcakes
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 4 cupcakes.
$16.00|Serves 4
Vanilla Cupcakes
Individual Packaging (Opt)
With vanilla buttercream.
$4.00
Cranberry Carrot Cupcake
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Cranberry cupcake with cream cheese frosting.
$4.00

Build-Your-Own 8-Pack Cupcakes
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 8 cupcakes.
$16.00|Serves 8
Red Velvet Cupcakes
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Red velvet cupcake with cream cheese frosting.
$4.00
Daily Cupcake Option 1
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Baker's selection.
$4.00
Chocolate Cupcakes
Individual Packaging (Opt)
With chocolate buttercream.
$4.00
Daily Cupcake Option 2
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Baker's selection.
$4.00
Daily Cupcake Option 3
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Baker's selection.
$4.00
Cookies
Build-Your-Own 12-Pack of Cookies
Most ordered
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 12 cookies.
$44.00|Serves 12
Gluten-Free Vegan Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Most ordered
Individual Packaging (Opt)
$4.00
Triple Chocolate Chunk Cookies
Most ordered
Individual Packaging (Opt)
With dark and milk chocolate chunks.
$4.00
Peanut Butter Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
$4.00
Chai Spice Pecan Snickerdoodle Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Chai spiced sugar cookie topped with pecans and caramel.
$4.00

12-Pack Assorted Macarons
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Assorted macarons.
$40.00|Serves 12
Vegan Gingersnap Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
$4.00
Build-Your-Own 4-Pack of Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 4 cookies.
$16.00|Serves 4
Linzer Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
With raspberry jam filling.
$4.50
Sprinkle Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Sugar cookie with rainbow sprinkles.
$4.00
Chocolate Almond Oat Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
$4.00
Salted Nutella Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Chocolate cookie with Nutella and sea salt.
$4.00
Build-Your-Own 6-Pack of Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 6 cookies.
$24.00|Serves 6
Cookie of the Day
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Baker's selection.
$4.00
Build-Your-Own 8-Pack of Cookies
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Your choice of 8 cookies.
$32.00|Serves 8
Dessert Bars
Vegan Brownie
Most ordered
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Vegan brownie square with chocolate chips.
$4.50
Lemon Bar
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Lemon bar square.
$4.50
Fudge Brownie Bar
Individual Packaging (Opt)
With chocolate chips.
$4.50
The "Brookie"
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Half brownie half cookie with pretzels.
$4.50
Peanut Butter Bar
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Peanut butter bar square topped with chocolate.
$4.50
Bar of the Day
Individual Packaging (Opt)
Baker's selection.
$4.50
Cakes & Cake Pops
Assorted Cake Pops Dozen
Most ordered
Baker's selection.
$40.00|Serves 12
6" Classic Birthday Cake
Vanilla cake, buttercream, and raspberry jam.
$49.00|Serves 8
8" Cookie & Milk Cake
Vanilla cake, chocolate cake with vanilla and chocolate buttercream, filled with chocolate chunk cookies inside.
$75.30|Serves 12
6" Double Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream.
$49.00|Serves 8
6" Rainbow Cake
5 layers of rainbow cake with vanilla buttercream.
$60.70|Serves 12
Pies & Breads
Salted Nutella Pecan Pie
With signature pecan filling swirled with Nutella. Topped with salted Nutella drizzle and a sprinkle of sea salt.
$45.00|Serves 6
Buttermilk Pie
With custard filling. Topped with raw brown sugar and sea salt.
$35.60|Serves 6
Miscellaneous
Birthday Candles
$4.00
About Buttermilk Bake Shop Catering
On ezCater.com since May 15th, 2020.
Address
530 3rd Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11215
Brooklyn, NY 11215
Delivery Hours
Tue-Sun: 11am-6pmTakeout Hours
Tue-Sun: 11am-6pmDelivery Fee
$25.00 & up to this locationCancelling your order
25% fee if canceled within 24 hours of event timeDelivery Minimum
$50.00 minimum for Delivery