Nov 03 2017
Renee Frojo
4 Minutes to read

Indianapolis has emerged as one of the U.S. top food destinations. The city received a spot on the Zagat list of hottest food cities. And Bon Appetit even compared its restaurant scene to Brooklyn’s. With a focus on fresh ingredients, all things local, and really good food, here are the best Indianapolis caterers to look out for.

Salsa Verde - Fajita bar

Salsa Verde (Indianapolis)

View their catering menu

For lunch, it doesn’t get more fun than building your own fajita bar. Sala Verde is modern and casual. And it relies on traditional Mexican recipes. But what’s great is that they use the best ingredients they can source locally. With a variety of options — from grilled mixed vegetables, to refried beans and pork — you should have no trouble keeping everyone in your group well fed and satisfied. But a word of warning: locals say their cheese dip is addictive.

Nameless BBQ Bar

Nameless Catering Company (Indianapolis)

View their catering menu

If you’re looking for a spot to make ordering as easy and seamless as possible, look no further than Nameless Catering Company. All of the Nameless catering packages come with everything you need, including salads, drinks, desserts, and sides. One of their most popular orders (especially with vegetarians) is the baked potato bar. It comes fully stocked with toppings like warm nacho cheese, homemade salsa, broccoli, butter, ground beef, and bean chili. That’s comfort food at it’s finest.

Red Habanero

Red Habanero (Fishers)

View their catering menu

Red Habanero is another excellent option when you’re in the mood for Mexican. This local spot has become known for its creative burritos. A notable favorite is the wet burrito with cilantro cream queso. Just be careful. It definitely brings the spice. For a creative catering appetizer option, check out the popular taco and nacho bar. It includes a plethora of tasting topping options like grilled chicken, ground beef, pico de gallo, corn, and salsas.

Indy Fresh - The Italian

Indy Fresh Catering (Indianapolis)

View their catering menu

With more than 100,000 events under its belt, Indy Fresh Catering knows what they’re doing. From ordering to drop-off, you know this Indianapolis caterer will always deliver the goods for taste and service. If you’re looking for breakfast, it’s an obvious choice. Indy’s french toast buffet comes with fruit, homemade rum caramel, and a side of bacon or sausage. Lunch packages include the skinny box, which has low-carb wraps for a healthier option. Or go for the Italian, which comes with signature salads, pasta, and one entree choice of either fettuccine with meat sauce, grilled lemon caper fish, or Italian sausage, peppers, and onions.

Pita Pit - Mediterranean Pita Platter

Pita Pit (Indianapolis)

View their catering menu

When you’ve got Mediterranean on the mind, Pita Pit should be your go-to. They believe you don’t have to sacrifice healthy eating for a quick and delicious meal. The soft pita bread is ideal for stuffing. For omnivores, that means lean grilled meats, crunchy vegetables, cheeses, and savory sauces. Protein-rich vegetarian options include savory falafel, spicy black beans, and hummus. It has options for everyone, which is why it’s one of the best Indianapolis caterers.

Firehouse Subs - ThisHouseIsOnFire

Firehouse Subs: Indianapolis

View their catering menu

Firehouse Subs is a national franchise with wide appeal, earning their reputation for quality and consistency. The fully loaded subs are unique because Firehouse steams their meats and cheeses. Popular sandwich combos include provolone and ham, and roast beef with Genoa salami. But, you’ll find all the classic options you’re craving. When you have a group to feed, the deluxe sub platters are the way to go. They come with chips, mayo, mustard, and a pickle to top things off.

Food Guys Catering: Indianapolis

View their catering menu

For a classic American food, Food Guys Catering never disappoints. The three-year-old company quickly made a name for itself among Indianapolis caterers for its easy customization options and stellar customer service. A popular dish is their signature fried chicken. It comes with a side of sweet fuji apple salad, candied carrots, and, of course, the gouda mac-n-cheese. That smoked flavor will stay with you for days.

Famous Daves BBQ - Assortment

Famous Dave’s BBQ (Noblesville)

View their catering menu

Famous Dave’s BBQ is known for a few things. Succulent pork, brisket, and chicken cooked to perfection are their claim to fame. This Indianapolis caterer has been recognized all over the country for multiple awards, including best ribs, best chicken wings, and best sauce. You don’t have to play it safe here, everything is good. Try the Piglet Meals, which include your choice of Georgia chopped pork, Texas beef brisket, or pulled barbecue chicken, along with a variety of sides. The garlic red-skin mashed potatoes are a particular favorite, as is the creamy coleslaw and the buttered corn niblets. They have everything you need for that perfect barbecue feast.

Sub Zero Ice Cream

Sub Zero Ice Cream & Yogurt (Indianapolis)

View their catering menu

When it’s time for dessert — and when isn’t it? — Sub Zero Ice Cream & Yogurt has you covered. They make all of their treats on site with a liquid nitrogen technology that creates the ice cream made-to-order. With options for virtually everyone, the menu includes classic cream, as well as low-fat, low-sugar, sugar-free, and dairy-free yogurts. Flavors include amaretto, caramel, coconut, Nutella, and raspberry with add-ins like Andes mints, almonds, cookie dough, and sprinkles. Ice cream socials have never tasted so good.

Are you in the Indianapolis area looking to order for your next company lunch or big event?

Start your search here

Written by:

Renee Frojo

Renee Frojo is an award-winning journalist, photographer, food stylist and recipe developer based in the San Francisco Bay Area. With equal time spent in and around the kitchen, Renee’s writing focuses on food, restaurants, hospitality and sustainability. Her writing and photography has appeared in a number of local and international publications, including Eater, the San Francisco Chronicle and the San Francisco Business Times. Her latest musing on food can be found at

Posted in: Trends in FoodThe Best Of

Tagged with: Caterer Round Up, Catering, Food Ordering, IN, Indianapolis