Arrow Right Icon
Your order has been switched to takeout
Arrow Right Icon
Check if caterer can deliver
Caterer delivers here!
Arrow Right Icon
Check when caterer can deliver
Caterer is available at this time!
Arrow Right Icon
Select date
Select time

Our Cupcakery

54 South High St, Dublin, OH
Baking up cupcakes, cakes, cookies, and other desserts for all occasions. Our dessert trays make company meetings and celebrations sweeter.  With the exception of almond and peanut butter flavors, all our cakes are nut-free. Make your next meeting memorable, tastefully! - Our Cupcakery
Our Cupcakery Logo

Catering Menu

Filter by Diet

Cupcakes

Dozen Traditional Size Cupcakes
Most Orderedserves 12
Your choices of cake flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$39.00
$39.00
Dozen Mini Size Cupcakes
serves 6
Your choices of flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$26.40
$26.40
Dozen Traditional Size “Signature Flavor” Cupcakes
serves 12
Includes backwards buckeye (chocolate cake, ganache filling & peanut butter buttercream frosting), raspberry lemonade (lemon cake, raspberry, filling & buttercream frosting), birthday cake (funfetti cake, cake batter buttercream & filling & frosting), Dublin Irish cream (dark chocolate cake, coffee bcf filling & irish buttercream frosting), lovin’ lemon (lemon cake, lemon filling & lemon bcf), raspberry almond (almond cake, raspberry filling & almond buttercream frosting), salty caramel (vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream filling & caramel buttercream frosting, drizzle), strawberry cream (strawberry cake, cream cheese filling & frosting), strawberry shortcake (vanilla cake, strawberry filling & strawberry buttercream frosting), triple chocolate (dark chocolate cake, ganache filling, & chocolate buttercream frosting), cookies n’ cream (cookies n’ cream cake & vanilla bcf), and chocolate chip cookie dough (vanilla cake w/ chocolate chip cookie dough baked in & cookie dough frosting).
$47.40
$47.40
Dozen Traditional Size Assorted Cupcakes
serves 12
Includes 3 vanilla, (vanilla buttercream) 3 chocolate (chocolate buttercream), 3 red velvet (cream cheese frosting), and 3 lemons (vanilla buttercream) cupcakes. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, and custom decoration are available, please call the store.]
$39.90
$39.90

Gluten-Free Cupcakes

Gluten-Free Dozen Mini Size Cupcakes
Most Orderedserves 6
Your choices of flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$32.40
Gluten-free
gluten_free
$32.40
Gluten-Free Dozen Traditional Size Cupcakes
serves 12
Your choices of cake flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$51.00
Gluten-free
gluten_free
$51.00
Gluten-Free Dozen King-Sized Cupcakes
serves 12
Your choices of flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$74.70
Gluten-free
gluten_free
$74.70

Vegan Cupcakes

Vegan Dozen Mini Size Cupcakes
Most Orderedserves 6
Your choices of flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$32.40
Vegan
vegan
$32.40
Vegan Dozen Traditional Size Cupcakes
serves 12
Your choices of cake flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$51.00
Vegan
vegan
$51.00
Vegan Dozen King-Sized Cupcakes
serves 12
Your choices of flavors, frostings, and toppings. [Other assortments or customizations: colored/flavored icing, decoration are available, please call store.]
$74.40
Vegan
vegan
$74.40

Cakes

Round Layered Cake
Most Orderedserves 10
Your choices of flavor, frosting, and topping. Message included with up to 4 words.
$36.50
$36.50
Rectangle Sheet Cake
serves 20
Your choices of flavor, frosting, and topping. Frosting border decoration included. Customizations (one color scheme & message) please add to special instructions. Message included with up to 4 words.
$58.00
$58.00
Ombre Rosette Cake
serves 10
With your choice of color.
$48.50
$48.50
Rectangle Sugar-Free Sheet Cake
serves 20
Your choices of flavor, frosting, and topping. Message included with up to 4 words.
$58.00
$58.00

Signature Cakes

Birthday Cake
Most Orderedserves 10
Funfetti cake, cake batter buttercream & filling & frosting.
$45.00
$45.00
placeholder image
Block “O” Cake
serves 15
Chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream filling, and vanilla buttercream frosting. 2-dimensional layer cake to resemble a block O.
$45.00
$45.00
Salty Caramel Cake
serves 10
Vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream filling & caramel buttercream frosting, drizzle.
$45.00
$45.00
placeholder image
Cookies n’ Cream Cake
serves 10
Cookies n’ cream cake & vanilla buttercream filling & frosting.
$45.00
$45.00
placeholder image

Gluten-Free Cakes

Round Gluten-Free Layered Cake
Most Orderedserves 10
Your choices of flavor, frosting, and topping.
$46.50
Gluten-free
gluten_free
$46.50
Rectangle Gluten-Free Sheet Cake
serves 20
Your choices of flavor, frosting, and topping.
$58.00
Gluten-free
gluten_free
$58.00

Vegan Cakes

Round Vegan Layered Cake
Most Orderedserves 10
Your choices of flavor, frosting, and topping.
$46.50
Vegan
vegan
$46.50
Vegan Sheet Cake
serves 20
Your choices of flavor, frosting, and topping.
$58.00
Vegan
vegan
$58.00

Desserts

Bakery Bites Sampler
individual packaging (opt)
serves 12
Assorted mini cupcakes, bite-sized chocolate chip cookies, and fudge brownies in a pastry box. Figure 2 to 3 pieces per person.
$50.00
$50.00
Buckeye Candies
$1.00
$1.00
Buckeye Bite Bakery Sampler
individual packaging (opt)
serves 16
Assorted mini cupcakes, Buckeye candy, bite-sized chocolate chip cookies, and fudge brownies in a pastry box. Figure 2 to 3 pieces per person.
$60.00
$60.00
Dozen Brownies Bite Sizes
individual packaging (opt)
serves 8
$24.00
$24.00

Cart
Shopping Cart Icon

Shopping Cart Icon

Please wait while we load up the food in your cart.

Powered by ezCater