Arrow Right Icon
Your order has been switched to takeout
Arrow Right Icon
Check if caterer can deliver
Caterer delivers here!
Arrow Right Icon
Check when caterer can deliver
Caterer is available at this time!
Arrow Right Icon
This caterer's online-order cut-off time has passed. Find available caterers.
Select date
Select time

First Choice Catering

4260 S 76th St, Greenfield, WI
|
Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled Star
5.0
|
Filled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled StarFilled Star
5.0
4260 S 76th St, Greenfield, WI
 - First Choice Catering
First Choice Catering Logo

Seasonal Specials

Classic Holiday Buffet
individual packaging (opt)
Includes your choices of entrees, side, & 2 vegetables, holiday tossed salad (spring mix w/ tomato, red onion, carrot & cranberry vinaigrette), rolls & butter, cranberry sauce, and assortment of christmas cookies. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.00
$18.00
Elegant Holiday Buffet
individual packaging (opt)
Includes your choices of 2 entrees, 2 sides & 2 vegetables, mixed greens salad (mixed greens w/ fresh blueberries, candied walnuts, bleu cheese & balsamic vinaigrette), rolls & butter, cranberry sauce, and pumpkin & pecan pie (w/ whipped cream). Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$20.00
$20.00
Santa's Elf Holiday Appetizers
individual packaging (opt)
minimum 15
Includes your choice of 7 appetizers. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.95
$18.95
Assorted Holiday Petit Fours
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.50
$3.50
Mother Claus Holiday Appetizers
individual packaging (opt)
minimum 15
Includes your choice of 7 appetizers. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$20.95
$20.95
Assorted Holiday Bars
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.50
$3.50
Assorted Christmas Cookies
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.00
$3.00

Breakfast

Good Morning Breakfast
individual packaging (opt)
Includes scrambled eggs, bacon, your choice of sausage, potatoes O'Brien, assorted bagels & muffins, and fresh fruit. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$11.95
$11.95
Continental Breakfast
individual packaging (opt)
Assorted donuts, Danish, bagels, and muffins. Served with fresh fruit, cream cheese, jam, and butter. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$9.95
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$9.95
Country Breakfast
individual packaging (opt)
Includes scrambled eggs, biscuits, sausage gravy, bacon, and fresh fruit. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$11.95
$11.95
Baked Oatmeal
individual packaging (opt)
With dried cranberries, spiced apples, and vanilla cream sauce. Served with fruit salad and assorted muffins. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$9.00
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$9.00
Homemade Pancakes
individual packaging (opt)
Your choice of pancakes served with your choice of breakfast meat. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$10.50
$10.50
Build-Your-Own Breakfast Burrito
individual packaging (opt)
Everything you need to build your own burritos, including scrambled eggs, your choice of breakfast meat, cheese, green peppers, tomatoes, onions, cilantro, salsa, and flour tortillas. Served with fresh fruit and your choice of potatoes. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$11.50
$11.50
Farmers Market Breakfast Casserole
individual packaging (opt)
Baked egg casserole with Italian chicken sausage, onions, mushrooms, hash browns, cheddar, green peppers, and tomatoes. Served with fresh fruit and assorted bagels & muffins. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$12.95
$12.95

Appetizers

Fresh Fruit Platter
individual packaging (opt)
serves 15
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$54.95
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$54.95
Street Skewers
individual packaging (opt)
serves 15
Assorted beef bulgogi, lemongrass pork, and chicken satay skewers. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$59.95
$59.95
Artisan Cheese Platter
individual packaging (opt)
serves 15
Aged cheddar, Havarti, Manchego, and blue cheese. Served with baguette, crackers, dried fruit, nuts, and preserves. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$81.95
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$81.95
Hummus Trio
individual packaging (opt)
serves 15
Classic, harissa red pepper, and basil pesto hummus. Served with pita bread, pita chips, cucumber, bell pepper, and grape tomatoes. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$49.95
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$49.95

Catering Packages

Italian Buffet
individual packaging (opt)
Includes your choices of two entrees & two sides, salad, and bread & butter. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.00
$18.00
All-American Picnic Package
individual packaging (opt)
Includes your choice of two proteins, lettuce, tomato, onion, sliced American cheese, pickles, chips & dip, baked beans, potato salad, and buns. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$13.00
$13.00
2-Entree Executive Buffet
individual packaging (opt)
Includes your choices of two entrees, two sides, vegetable & salad and fresh dinner rolls. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$20.00
$20.00
2-Entree Grand Buffet
individual packaging (opt)
Includes your choices of two entrees, two sides, vegetable & salad and fresh dinner rolls. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.00
$18.00

Picnic & Tailgate Catering Packages

Picnic & Tailgate Package
individual packaging (opt)
minimum 25
Includes your choices of 3 meats & 3 sides, kettle chips, buns & condiments, and assorted cookies. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$15.95
$15.95
Southern BBQ Picnic
individual packaging (opt)
minimum 25
Includes your choices of 2 entrees & 3 sides, buns, kettle chips, condiments, and assorted cookies. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$20.00
$20.00
Ole Border Fiesta
individual packaging (opt)
minimum 25
Includes your choices of 3 entrees & 3 sides, tortilla chips & salsa, and churros. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$18.95
$18.95
Borderline Picnic
individual packaging (opt)
minimum 25
Includes your choices of 3 entrees & 3 sides, kettle chips, buns, condiments, assorted cookies, and churros. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$16.95
$16.95

Weddings & Special Events Catering Packages

The Original
individual packaging (opt)
Includes your choices of salad, 2 entrees, sides, potatoes & vegetables, and dinner rolls. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$25.00
$25.00
Appetizers Two
individual packaging (opt)
Your choice of 4 appetizers. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$8.00
$8.00
Dark Chocolate Brownie
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.00
$3.00
Appetizers One
individual packaging (opt)
Your choice of 4 appetizers. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$7.00
$7.00

Boxed Lunches

Salad Box Lunch
individual packaging
minimum 5
Each box includes your choice of salad, Italian bread & butter, and a cookie. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$9.25
$9.25
Artisanal Sandwich Box Lunch
individual packaging
minimum 5
Each box includes your choices of sandwich & side, a pickle, chips, and a cookie. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$13.00
$13.00
Sandwich Box Lunch
individual packaging
minimum 5
Each box includes your choices of sandwich & side, a pickle, chips, and a cookie. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$11.00
$11.00

Sandwiches & Wraps

Deli Wrap & Sandwich Buffet
individual packaging (opt)
Your choice of up to four sandwiches. Served with chips and your choice of two sides. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$13.00
$13.00
Soup & Sandwich Pick-2 Buffet
individual packaging (opt)
Your choice of two items. Served with your choice of side, bread & butter, and oyster crackers. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$14.00
$14.00
Deli Board
individual packaging (opt)
Everything you need to make your own sandwiches, including your choices of three meats & two cheeses, assorted rolls & breads, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pepperoncini, pickles, mustard, and mayo. Served with chips and your choice of two sides. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$12.00
$12.00
Mini Sandwich Platter
individual packaging (opt)
serves 6
Assorted mini curried chicken salad, roasted turkey (w/ cranberry mayo), tomato, mozzarella & basil (w/ balsamic mayo), and roast beef (w/ cheddar & Dijon) sandwiches. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$36.00
$36.00

Tacos & Fajitas

Taco Bar
individual packaging (opt)
Everything you need to make your own tacos, including ground beef, shredded chicken, tortillas, and a condiment platter. Served with rice & beans and chips & salsa. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$12.00
$12.00
Street Taco Bar
individual packaging (opt)
Everything you need to make your own street tacos, including your choice of two proteins, fresh cilantro, shredded lettuce, guacamole, tomatoes, onions, lime crema, and corn & flour tortillas. Served with Mexican rice and fresh fruit. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$17.00
$17.00
Make-Your-Own Fajitas
individual packaging (opt)
Everything you need to make your own fajitas, including marinated & seasoned grilled chicken & steak, sauteed onions, red & green peppers, and flour tortillas. Served with refried beans, red rice, shredded cheese, jalapenos, salsa, sour cream, tortilla chips, and churros. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$15.00
$15.00

Hot Entrees

Chicken Kluski
Most Orderedserves 8
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$45.00
$45.00

Salads

Salad Bar
individual packaging (opt)
Everything you need to make your own salads, including fresh romaine, mixed greens, your choices of two proteins & up to five toppings, and assorted dressings. Served with Italian bread & butter, fresh fruit, and pasta salad. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$13.50
$13.50
Cobb Salad
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$6.00
$6.00
Apple Pecan Arugula Salad
serves 8
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$50.00
$50.00

Sides

Potato Bar
individual packaging (opt)
Everything you need to make your own loaded potatoes, including your choices of potatoes & up to five toppings, sour cream, butter, and house salad (w/ assorted dressings). Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$13.50
$13.50
Steamed Spinach
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$1.50
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$1.50
Avocado
individual packaging
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$2.00
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$2.00
Roasted Potato Wedges
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.00
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$3.00

Hors D'Oeuvres

Rumaki
individual packaging (opt)
serves 12
24 pieces of Bacon-wrapped chestnuts with soy glaze. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$39.95
$39.95
Ricotta & Black Olive Crostini
individual packaging (opt)
serves 12
24 pieces with lemon zest and mint. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$42.95
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$42.95
Tomato Bruschetta
individual packaging (opt)
serves 12
24 pieces of Italian baguette topped with diced tomato & onion, garlic, olive oil, and fresh basil. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$42.95
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$42.95
Prosciutto-Wrapped Mozzarella & Basil
individual packaging (opt)
serves 12
24 pieces with cherry tomatoes and balsamic glaze. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$54.95
$54.95
Cucumber Canapés
individual packaging (opt)
serves 12
24 pieces with herbed cream cheese & mayo, diced pimento, and dill on rye bread. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$40.95
Vegetarian
vegetarian
$40.95

Desserts

Chocolate Chip Cookies
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$2.00
$2.00
Apple Strudel
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.00
$3.00
Dark Chocolate Brownies
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.00
$3.00
Mini Cannoli
individual packaging (opt)
Crispy pastry shells with sweet ricotta filling. Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$3.00
$3.00
New York Cheesecake
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$4.00
$4.00
Chocolate Fudge Cake Sensation
individual packaging (opt)
Be sure to purchase utensils if you'll need them (from the Miscellaneous category).
$4.00
$4.00

Beverages

Coffee Pot
Most Orderedserves 12
$15.95
$15.95
Orange Bottled Juice
$2.50
$2.50
Apple Bottled Juice
$2.50
$2.50
Coffee Service
serves 75
$90.00
$90.00

Miscellaneous

Utensils
Most Ordered
$2.00
$2.00

Extended Services

On-site Attendant Service
Most Ordered
Includes on-site setup, food handling, and takedown. Priced per hour.
$24.95
$24.95

Cart
Shopping Cart Icon

Shopping Cart Icon

Please wait while we load up the food in your cart.

Powered by ezCater